New York, Los Angeles and Chicago, the three largest school systems in the United States, are weighing whether to drop Google Search after the company refused to sell schools a version of the product without its artificial intelligence tools. The three districts serve 1.57 million students between them, and each has asked Google for a Google Search product with the AI stripped out. Google said no.
Google told the New York Times that schools which switch off its Gemini-powered AI tools will also lose access to Google Search. Chris Phillips, Google’s vice president and general manager for education, told the Times: ‘Search and AI are deeply integrated,’ and said schools that switch off the AI tools ‘will not have access to Search.’ The change is due to take effect at the start of the 2027-28 school year.
The dispute turns on control. Google announced on 3 November that, from next year, its Gemini app, Gemini Notebook, Gemini in Classroom and Google Search will be switched off by default for school accounts, and administrators will choose which services to switch back on. A district that turns the AI tools off will find Search switched off too.
Google Search tied to Gemini in school accounts
Google spokesperson Laura Breen said the company is updating its approach to school controls after feedback from educators. She said the Gemini app, Gemini Notebook and Google Search will be off by default in 2027 until schools decide which services to enable. What she did not say is whether a school will be able to enable Search on its own, without the AI tools that come with it.
That gap is the heart of the dispute. New York City, Los Angeles and Chicago all want a search tool that works without AI-generated answers, and Google’s position is that Search cannot be separated from the AI behind it. Phillips told the Times that the company cannot split Search from its AI because the two are deeply integrated.
How the districts answered
New York City schools chancellor Kamar H. Samuels said in a statement to the Times: ‘If Google doesn’t reconsider their position, we will explore other search options.’ His warning leaves Google Search as the service the districts may have to give up. Chicago’s public schools told Google that if it cannot provide a version of Search without AI, ‘the district will look to other search solutions.’ Los Angeles Unified has already switched off Google’s AI Overviews for students, and its chief information officer, Jack Kelanic, told a meeting of the district’s school board AI committee that the district could change its default search engine ‘literally overnight.’
New York City mayor Zohran Mamdani called Google’s move ‘extortion,’ and Senator Bernie Sanders echoed that criticism. Mamdani announced in September a one-year moratorium on AI use by public school students from 2-K through eighth grade. New York City Council Speaker Julie Menin and Council Member Shekar Krishnan wrote to Google chief executive Sundar Pichai on 13 November and asked for written answers by 19 November.
Chicago blocks access to AI tools, including ChatGPT and Gemini, on school devices, in order to protect student privacy and safety. Los Angeles and New York have also placed limits on AI in schools, and the three districts are now testing their exits from Google in parallel.
What Google Search alternatives are on the table
DuckDuckGo and Microsoft’s Bing are the alternatives to Google Search under discussion, and both let users switch off AI-generated answers. Los Angeles has said it could move its default search engine quickly, and Chicago has said it will look elsewhere if Google cannot supply Search without AI. New York has not named a replacement, but Samuels has made clear that the city will look for one if Google holds its position.
The districts have time before the new Google Search controls take effect, and Google has said it will give schools more details before the rollout. The council’s letter to Pichai asked for written answers by 19 November, and the districts are waiting to see what the company says.

