Chris Columbus has said he had to fire the actor first cast as Marv in Home Alone, calling it the only firing of his career. The director spoke about the casting on a recent episode of the Wildmen podcast, hosted by Dylan Sprouse and Brendan Columbus. The 1990 film starred Macaulay Culkin as Kevin McCallister, a boy left behind by his family who defends his house against two burglars, Harry and Marv.
How the Home Alone cast came together
Columbus said he had wanted Daniel Stern and Joe Pesci to play Marv and Harry in Home Alone, the pair known as the Wet Bandits. The studio would pay for only one of them, so Columbus chose Pesci, who played Harry, and another actor was brought in to play Marv. “I conceived of Dan Stern and Joe Pesci in this movie as the bad guys. And they said, ‘You only get one.’ So I said, ‘Okay, let’s go with Pesci,'” Columbus said.
The replacement did not work out. “We did a screen test and they were horrible. I mean, Pesci was great. This other kid was, and he was a kid at the time, he was just awful. And I had to, that’s the only person I ever had to fire,” Columbus said. He did not name the actor during the interview.
The actor who lost the Home Alone role
The actor is widely understood to be Daniel Roebuck. In 2023, Roebuck said on the What a Character! podcast that he had been the actor cast as Marv before Stern, and that he was fired from the film. “I was never gonna be Marv. Now that’s the one thing they never say. I was never ever ever going to film as Marv,” Roebuck said at the time.
Entertainment Weekly contacted Roebuck about Columbus’s new comments, and the actor pushed back on the director’s account. “I have enormous respect for Chris Columbus. I’ve enjoyed all of his movies. But I find these comments troubling. They did everything they could to get me to quit. There was no screen test with Joe Pesci. That never ever happened, so that’s impossible,” Roebuck said.
Roebuck said on the podcast that he was never going to film as Marv, a point he has repeated since. His account differs from Columbus’s on a central detail: Roebuck says there was no screen test with Pesci, while Columbus describes a screen test that went badly.
Columbus said he broke the news to the actor himself and told him they would work together at some point. The two have never worked together since. Columbus directed Home Alone and its sequel, Home Alone 2, and the films made the Wet Bandits one of the best-known pairings in family films.
A Christmas film that still draws talk
Home Alone was released in 1990 and became one of the most successful family films of its era. Culkin played Kevin, an eight-year-old left behind when his family flies to Paris for Christmas, and Pesci and Stern played the burglars who try to break into the house. The traps and chases in Home Alone made it a fixture of Christmas viewing, and it returns to television and streaming every holiday season.
The casting story has come up before, but Columbus’s account on the Wildmen podcast gave it new attention this week. The podcast is hosted by Dylan Sprouse and Brendan Columbus, the director’s son. The interview covered the making of Home Alone and the choices behind its cast, including the decision to keep Pesci and recast Marv. Columbus also directed Mrs. Doubtfire and the first two Harry Potter films.
Stern went on to play Marv in Home Alone and its sequel, and the role became one of the best-known of his career. Roebuck has continued to act since, and he has spoken about the firing on podcasts before. The two accounts differ on whether a screen test with Pesci took place at all.
The film has stayed in regular rotation at Christmas for more than three decades, and its cast has talked about it in interviews ever since. Columbus has spoken about the production before, but the firing story had not drawn this much attention until the podcast episode aired.

