Consumers can handle a stock crash better than most people assume, according to a new analysis from the Peterson Institute for International Economics. The study, published on November 17, looks at what would happen to spending if the artificial intelligence boom turns out to be a bubble.
The answer is less alarming than the headlines suggest. If a stock crash cut the market by 25 percent, spending cutbacks would reduce economic growth by about 0.6 percentage point over the next year, according to the author’s preferred estimate. That figure looks only at the effect of the market decline on consumption, ignoring other channels that could worsen or soften the blow. The effect could reach 3.4 percentage points, but the author views that as a very remote tail risk.
The analysis is the third in a series of five posts on how exposed the economy is if the AI boom turns out to be a bubble.
How a stock crash would hit spending
The study examines three scenarios: a baseline 25 percent decline, which market pricing puts at less than a 10 percent chance of lasting through the end of 2027; a bad case of 35 percent; and a severe case of 50 percent, which market pricing puts at about 2 percent.
The reason a stock crash would hurt spending less than expected is that consumers have been surprisingly careful with their recent gains. Historically, people have spent about 3 cents of every $1 rise in stock wealth. In the current boom they appear to have spent more like 1 cent of every dollar of gains, and possibly less.
That means they would not need to cut spending back sharply on the way down. The Federal Reserve’s FRB/US model has a wealth effect of roughly 1 cent per dollar, and its prediction matches post-COVID consumption data well, which suggests it is a reasonable guide to what would happen after a stock crash.
The 2001 lesson for a stock crash
History backs the point. The 2001 recession, which followed the bursting of the dot-com bubble, was barely a result of consumer spending cutbacks after the market fell. It was the least consumer-driven recession in both relative and absolute terms in the postwar period.
Consumer spending slowed but it never went negative. During its worst four quarters it still grew 1.8 percent. The drag from consumer spending in 2001 was only 0.5 percentage point, against a median of 2.0 points in other postwar recessions, and it made up only 21 percent of the shortfall in output growth, against 44 percent in the median of the others.
The surprise that drove the 2001 recession was almost entirely in investment. Real business investment fell for eight straight quarters, dropping 12 percent from the end of 2000 to the end of 2002. The market had fallen by half. But the spending of ordinary households held up through the stock crash.
Why a stock crash is bigger on paper now
There is a case for worrying, and the study does not hide it. The total value of the US stock market has grown from an average of 65 percent of GDP from 1952 to 1995, to 187 percent at the dot-com peak in early 2000, to a record 286 percent in mid-2026. A stock crash of 25 percent today would wipe out about as much household wealth, relative to the size of the economy, as the halving of the market did after 2000: about 57 percent of GDP, compared with the 61 percent households actually lost from early 2000 to late 2002.
Much of that wealth sits at the top. In mid-2026 the top 0.1 percent of households owned 25 percent of the stock and mutual funds held outside 401(k)s and pensions, up from 15 percent in 1989, and the top 10 percent owned 88 percent. The wealth of the 10 richest Americans in fall 2026 is $2.5 trillion higher than in fall 2019, according to Forbes. If a stock crash comes, those households will not cut their spending by anything like the amount their wealth drops.
Paul Samuelson famously quipped that the stock market “predicted nine out of the last five recessions.” The current tally is 17 of the last 9 since 1946 for declines of 20 percent or more. On October 19, 1987, the S&P 500 fell 20.5 percent in a single day, yet in the following year real GDP grew 3.8 percent and real consumer spending grew 4.6 percent.
The stock crash scenario is real, but the evidence in the study points the same way: households have spent little of their recent gains, and a fall would take less out of their spending than the size of the market suggests.

