Netflix has a new number one movie, and it is the kind of holiday romance that knows exactly what it is. Guarding Stars, which arrived on the streaming service on November 18, has climbed to the top of the Netflix movie chart with a fake-dating plot, a snowy Montana ranch and two leads who lean into every Christmas movie cliche along the way.
The film stars Leighton Meester as Hannah Brooks, a no-nonsense bodyguard hired to protect famous action star Jack Stapleton, played by Jared Padalecki, from a persistent stalker. Her assignment takes her to his family’s ranch in Montana just in time for Christmas. There is one complication: when Jack’s family mistakes Hannah for his girlfriend, the two decide to play along.
Guarding Stars is based on Katherine Center’s 2022 romance novel, The Bodyguard. The book built a large readership before the film was announced, and the adaptation keeps the novel’s central setup: a professional bodyguard who has to guard a celebrity, and the pretend relationship that follows once his family gets the wrong idea.
Guarding Stars and its holiday romance plot
The plot of Guarding Stars runs through the familiar beats of the genre. Hannah arrives as an outsider with a job to do. Jack is a film star who needs protection. His family home in Montana provides the snowy setting, and the fake relationship gives the two leads a reason to spend Christmas together under one roof.
Meester plays Hannah as direct and practical, a bodyguard who takes the work seriously even when the situation turns awkward. Padalecki plays Jack as a famous actor who is used to attention but not to having a bodyguard at the family Christmas table. The film also features Andie MacDowell among the supporting cast.
The casting pairs two actors with long television histories. Meester is best known for Gossip Girl, where she played Blair Waldorf, while Padalecki spent 15 seasons on Supernatural as Sam Winchester. Both have moved between television and film since, and the new film puts them together for the first time in a holiday romance built around a Montana ranch at Christmas.
What the film does with that setup is what has caught viewers’ attention. Rather than treating the Christmas movie format as something to rise above, Guarding Stars works inside it, and the audience reaction so far suggests that is the point.
Guarding Stars viewers react on Rotten Tomatoes
Audiences have already started weighing in on Rotten Tomatoes, and the reactions are close to what a feel-good holiday romance usually draws. One viewer called it “a Hallmark-esque movie with real production value, solid casts and a script that knows it’s a cheesy Christmas movie and leans into it, makes fun of itself, and still hits all the Christmas movie tropes.”
Another viewer praised the pairing at the centre of the film, writing that it was a “Wonderful movie with all the Christmas spirit. The actors showed great chemistry, their actions were so natural and the plot quickly captivates you.” A third summed it up in a few words: “Love This Movie! This movie is funny and heartwarming.”
Not every viewer was won over. One less-than-impressed viewer described it as a “drama train wreck”, a reminder that even the most cheerful Christmas romances do not land with everyone.
Guarding Stars tops the Netflix chart
Guarding Stars reached the top of the Netflix movie chart within a day of its release on November 18. It follows a run of holiday titles that have taken the number one spot in recent weeks, including Tyler Perry’s The Gospel of Christmas and Dennis Quaid’s A Dog’s Perfect Christmas, both of which topped the chart earlier in November.
The timing is part of the story. Christmas films arrive in force from early November, and Netflix’s chart tends to turn over quickly as new titles land. Guarding Stars is the latest to benefit from that pattern, with a well-known book behind it and two leads with large followings.
For viewers who want a holiday romance that plays the familiar notes without apology, Guarding Stars is streaming now on Netflix.

