The bottom of the stock market slump is still ahead of us, according to contrarian analysis. That is the verdict from Mark Hulbert, the MarketWatch columnist who tracks the sentiment of short-term market timers, and it rests on readings that have moved towards a buy signal without reaching it.
The stock market slump has already taken the S&P 500 to 6.3 percent below its early October high, and the Nasdaq Composite is 11.5 percent below its peak. Those are sizeable falls in the stock market slump, and they have pulled sentiment down with them. But contrarians look for something more specific than a fall in prices: they look for the moment when the people who trade the market turn bearish enough that the crowd has given up.
The stock market slump has not yet produced the reading contrarians wait for. Hulbert’s monitoring of short-term market timers shows they are less bullish than they were six weeks ago, but they have not yet become bearish enough to satisfy the criteria contrarians use for a buy signal.
Stock market slump sentiment is close but not there
The main measure is the Hulbert Stock Newsletter Sentiment Index, known as the HSNSI, which reflects the average recommended equity exposure among several dozen short-term market timers who focus on the broad stock market. It has declined to just the upper edge of the excessively bearish zone, which Hulbert defines as the range of readings in the bottom decile of the historical distribution.
Contrarian buy signals typically do not come until sentiment has dropped further into that zone and stays there for a number of trading sessions. The HSNSI is at the door, but it has not walked through it.
An even stronger indication that a buy signal would be premature comes from the Hulbert Nasdaq Newsletter Sentiment Index, or HNNSI, a similar measure that covers a different group of timers, those who focus on the Nasdaq market in particular. That index is further from the excessively bearish zone than the broad-market measure.
Other signs in the stock market slump
Other sentiment measures tell the same story. The weekly survey that the American Association of Individual Investors conducts of its members shows that those who say they are bullish, expressed as a percentage of those who are either bullish or bearish, just this week dipped to the upper end of what Hulbert has defined as the excessively bearish zone. It is the same pattern: close to the line, not past it.
The VIX, the Cboe Volatility Index, often called the investor-fear index, is currently pointing away from being in its excessively bearish zone. That is another sign that fear has not yet reached the level contrarians watch for.
Surging demand for Anthropic’s upcoming share sale provides yet more evidence of pockets of bullishness. The company’s initial public offering has reportedly been nearly seven times oversubscribed, which is not the behaviour of a market in which everyone has given up.
What contrarians watch next in the stock market slump
The logic behind contrarian analysis is simple enough: when most traders are bullish, there are few buyers left to push prices up, and when most are bearish, there are few sellers left to push prices down. That is why the bottom of a fall often comes when sentiment is at its worst, not when prices have merely fallen a long way.
Paul Samuelson famously quipped that the stock market “predicted nine out of the last five recessions.” Hulbert’s own count is that declines of 20 percent or more in the US stock market as a whole have called 17 of the last 9 recessions since 1946. The point is that market falls often arrive at the same time as recessions rather than before them, and many falls are caused by the same forces that bring the recession.
For now, the message from the sentiment data is that the stock market slump has further to go before contrarians will call a tradable bottom. Sentiment is moving in the right direction to entice them, but it is not there yet. The timers are less bullish than they were, the surveys are near the bearish zone, and the fear index has not joined them. Until those readings drop further and stay there, the bottom of the stock market slump remains ahead.

