Update (Oct 30, 2026): U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason has not yet ruled on the motions to dismiss. On Thursday, Oct. 29, the Justice Department filed an amended complaint. It adds a new claim under the Supremacy Clause and new allegations drawn from the New York Times report, and DOJ told the judge that the pending motions to dismiss are now moot because they target a complaint that no longer exists, CNBC and Democracy Docket reported. The relief DOJ is asking for is essentially unchanged. Alaska’s Division of Elections asked the judge for fast consideration of a motion to dismiss the amended complaint and said the court “should not tolerate this gamesmanship,” according to CNBC. Separately, Gov. Mike Dunleavy ordered the state Department of Public Safety to investigate whether the alleged recruitment of Daniel J. Sullivan broke state law, and the Alaska Bureau of Investigation has opened that inquiry, NBC News and the Anchorage Daily News reported. NBC News also reported, citing a U.S. official, that DOJ has issued at least three dozen new subpoenas and document preservation requests to the offices of Peltola’s campaign and of Daniel J. Sullivan’s campaign. Peltola’s campaign repeated that it “has no involvement with either Sullivan campaign,” and the DSCC said it “is not involved with Dan J. Sullivan.” No one has been charged.
Update (Nov. 1, 2026): Alaska has answered the Justice Department’s request to set aside ballots ranking Daniel J. Sullivan. In a 14-page filing on Saturday, Oct. 31, state attorneys again asked Judge Sharon Gleason to dismiss the suit and called the demand “inappropriate and not even possible given Alaska voters’ vital right to ballot secrecy,” the Anchorage Daily News and the Associated Press reported. The state argued that the only way to know whether a voter who ranked Daniel J. meant Dan S. would be to match the voter to her ballot, which can’t be done because ballots carry no names and are mixed together. It also noted that state policy already requires ballots to be kept for 22 months. Gleason agreed on Friday to consider the case on an expedited basis, which leaves open a ruling before Tuesday’s election, the ADN reported. She had not ruled as of Saturday night. Separately, Gov. Mike Dunleavy told NewsNation that if the state concludes anything illegal happened, “that may in fact impact whether somebody is seated in the U.S. Senate.” He did not say what law might have been broken, the ADN noted.
Update (Nov. 5, 2026): The race between Sen. Dan Sullivan and Democrat Mary Peltola is still uncalled after Tuesday’s election. As of late Wednesday morning, with nearly three-fourths of votes counted, Peltola led Sullivan by fewer than 1,000 first-choice votes and Daniel J. Sullivan had more than 3,500, The Washington Post reported. Neither leading candidate has passed 50%, so the result is likely to come down to ranked-choice tabulation. Alaska accepts overseas ballots for up to 15 days after Election Day, and state officials are targeting Nov. 18 for that count, the Associated Press reported. An Alaska Beacon analysis of the state’s early cast vote record found the senator would gain 2,728 votes and Peltola 1,868 once Republican Gerald Heikes and Daniel J. Sullivan are eliminated. Of the 3,426 Daniel J. Sullivan ballots in that record, 991 listed Peltola next and 560 listed the senator, which the Beacon said indicates “little, if any, voter confusion.” The Beacon cautioned that the record leaves out about 11,000 counted ballots, mostly from rural precincts that favor Peltola, plus early and absentee ballots not yet tallied. U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason dismissed the Justice Department’s suit on Nov. 1, and the department’s appeal is now before the Ninth Circuit, which has set a briefing schedule that runs into January, according to the Post. Federal authorities have confirmed a separate criminal investigation into how Daniel J. Sullivan entered the race. Peltola has denied any involvement, the AP reported. The senator’s campaign said Wednesday it was confident “despite the biggest election cheating scandal in the history of Alaska,” while Peltola said counting will “take a long time” to reach every remote community.
Update (Nov. 3, 2026): Judge Sharon Gleason has dismissed the Justice Department’s lawsuit. In a 20-page order on Sunday, Nov. 1, she ruled that the federal government lacked standing and offered “no workable plan as to how it proposes to segregate ballots cast for Daniel J. Sullivan on Election Day” while keeping votes secret, Alaska Public Media and CBS News reported. Gleason also wrote that ordering ballots set aside for a later investigation would likely cause voter “confusion and consequent incentive to remain away from the polls,” and that “late-breaking changes to the election rules are strongly disfavored,” according to JURIST. About an hour after the ruling, the Justice Department filed a notice of appeal. A department spokesperson told NPR, “Alaskan voters deserve a fair election, not to be misled in an attempt to rig outcomes.” CBS News reported that the department’s separate criminal investigation into an alleged plot to put Daniel J. Sullivan on the ballot is continuing and that no one in the race has been charged. For now, Tuesday’s election goes ahead with both Sullivans on the ballot and no order to set any ballots aside.
Nothing has happened to Alaska Sen. Dan Sullivan himself. He is still on the Nov. 3 ballot seeking a third term against Democrat Mary Peltola. The reason his name is trending is that a second Dan Sullivan is on the same ballot, and that is now a federal court case and a campaign scandal. On Oct. 22, the Justice Department sued to block certification of the Senate result if the senator loses narrowly. On Oct. 28, The New York Times reported that Peltola-aligned operatives recruited the other Sullivan to run. Peltola’s campaign denies any involvement. A federal judge could rule on dismissing the lawsuit as soon as Friday, Oct. 30.
Two Dan Sullivans, side by side
Most of the confusion online is about which Sullivan is which. Here is how the two candidates compare, based on reporting by Al Jazeera and Yahoo News.
| Sen. Dan S. Sullivan | Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. | |
|---|---|---|
| Who he is | Incumbent Republican senator, first elected in 2014 and reelected in 2020; former Alaska attorney general | Retired elementary schoolteacher and former U.S. Forest Service employee from Petersburg in southeast Alaska |
| How he appears on the ballot | “Sullivan, Dan S (Registered Republican) Incumbent” | “Sullivan, Daniel J Jr,” with no party designation |
| Party registration | Republican | Switched from unaffiliated to Republican just before the filing deadline, then back to unaffiliated, per Yahoo News |
| August primary result | About 41%, behind Peltola’s 49.5% | 4,107 votes, enough to finish in the top four |
| Prior campaigns | Statewide winner twice | Never before ran for public office |
| Position on the dispute | His campaign says Peltola’s team “colluded” to deceive voters | Says he is running in good faith and has denied any connection to Peltola’s campaign |
Alaska’s Division of Elections removed Daniel J. Sullivan from the ballot in June. State courts restored him, and the Alaska Supreme Court allowed him to stay on the ballot, Al Jazeera and Yahoo News reported.
What the Justice Department wants a judge to do
The federal suit, United States v. State of Alaska, was filed Oct. 22 in the U.S. District Court for Alaska. As NBC News described it, the department wants a court order blocking certification if two things are both true: Sen. Sullivan loses, and he would have won had every vote for Daniel J. Sullivan gone to him instead under the ranked-choice count. The filing argues that “some supporters of Senator Sullivan likely will inadvertently vote for Daniel J. Sullivan.”
President Trump has said he ordered the suit. “I’m the one that said do it,” he said, according to Yahoo News. The case relies on the National Voter Registration Act. Election law experts quoted by Al Jazeera and Yahoo News have questioned that basis. Notre Dame law professor Derek Muller called the argument “so absurdly thin” that it had “essentially no likelihood of success.” Alaska’s Republican-led state government and Peltola’s campaign have moved to dismiss the case, and the League of Women Voters of Alaska has sought to join it, arguing along with them that no law allows this kind of federal intervention. As of Al Jazeera’s Oct. 24 report, no court had ordered Alaska to suspend certification.
What The New York Times reported on Oct. 28
On Wednesday, the Times published an investigation into what it said was an effort internally called the “ballot composition project.” According to the Times, as summarized by Alaska Public Media and Yahoo News, people working with Peltola’s campaign, the campaign’s lawyers and senior aides at the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee (DSCC) took part in an effort to recruit Daniel J. Sullivan and other potential spoiler candidates to split the incumbent’s support. Yahoo News reported that the Times cited 12 people who took part in or were told of the plan, along with text messages and internal documents.
Points to keep in mind about the report:
- These are allegations. Alaska Public Media said it had not independently confirmed the Times’ reporting. No one has been charged.
- The campaign denies it. “The Alaskans for Mary campaign has no involvement with either Sullivan campaign,” Peltola’s campaign said, according to Alaska Public Media. Peltola called the story a distraction. The DSCC has also denied involvement.
- A key source tried to retract. Former Peltola campaign manager Elisa Rios, who was fired in August, spoke to the Times and later tried to take back her statements before publication, Yahoo News reported.
- Legality is disputed. The Times called ballot-stacking “generally considered legal,” per Yahoo News. A Republican National Committee spokesman told Alaska Public Media it could break federal campaign finance law if a super PAC coordinated with the campaign.
Reaction split along party lines. Trump wrote that Peltola “should suffer the Legal and Political consequences,” Alaska Public Media reported. Sen. Lisa Murkowski, who has endorsed Sullivan, said Alaskans “deserve the honest truth from Mary and her campaign.”
Our analysis: how ranked-choice voting changes the math
The lawsuit’s premise is that confused voters could cost the senator the race. Alaska’s ballot design makes that harder than it sounds, though not impossible. Voters rank the four finalists. If no one wins a majority of first choices, the last-place candidate is eliminated and those ballots move to each voter’s next choice.
Take a voter who meant to back the senator but marked Daniel J. Sullivan first by mistake. If that voter also ranked the senator second, the vote moves to the senator once the lesser-known Sullivan is eliminated. The ballot loses its value only if the voter ranked no one else, and Alaska Public Media noted that some voters in every race don’t rank their ballots. Political scientist Glenn Wright told Al Jazeera the system “is actually designed to cope with this sort of a thing.”
What that means for Alaska voters before Nov. 3:
- Read the party label and the word “Incumbent” next to each Sullivan.
- Rank more than one candidate if you want your ballot to count in later rounds.
- Early voting is heavy. More than 60,000 Alaskans had already voted by Wednesday, according to state figures reported by Alaska Public Media.
What happens next
U.S. District Judge Sharon L. Gleason put the case on a fast track on Oct. 26. Late Wednesday she let the Democratic-side challenge proceed and gave the Justice Department until Thursday afternoon to respond, according to Yahoo News. Alaska Public Media reported that a ruling on the motions to dismiss could come as soon as Friday afternoon. The race itself is close: the Cook Political Report rates it a toss-up, and recent polls show Peltola ahead by about 2 points, Yahoo News reported. Republicans hold 53 Senate seats to Democrats’ 47 (including two independents who caucus with them), so the seat could matter for control of the chamber.
We are tracking the ruling and Election Night results on our trends news page. More national coverage is in Top Stories.
More election explainers: the South Carolina Senate seat after Lindsey Graham’s death and Thomas Massie’s primary loss.
Updated Nov. 5, 2026

